The Vineyard - Matthew 21:33-46
ListenI was given a challenge for this song, and since I rarely back down from a challenge, I jumped into it with all the courage of a duckling jumping into a pond for the first time—nervous, a little unsure of what I was getting myself into, but excited for the experience.
Some of my bandmates had been looking ahead at our pastor's upcoming messages so they could pick relevant songs for the services. One of the messages was titled "Murder in the Vineyard," based on Matthew 21:33–46. Apparently, they found the title amusing enough that they started laughing among themselves and thought, as a joke, about asking me to write a song to go along with it.
So eventually the challenge made its way to me.
At the time, I had absolutely no idea what Matthew 21:33–46 was about. But I thought, Why not? How hard could it be?
Then I read it. Good grief!! What a story, what have I gotten myself into.
Jesus tells a story about a landowner who planted a vineyard. He put a wall around it, dug a winepress, built a watchtower, leased it to tenants, and then went away on a journey.
"There was a landowner who planted a vineyard. He put a wall around it, dug a winepress in it and built a watchtower." — Matthew 21:33
When harvest time came, the owner sent his servants to collect the fruit that belonged to him. Instead of giving the owner what was rightfully his, the tenants attacked the servants. They beat one, killed another, and stoned another.
So the owner sent more servants. The tenants treated them the same way.
Finally, the owner sent his son.
But when the tenants saw the son, they decided that if they killed the heir, perhaps they could keep the inheritance for themselves.
So they threw him outside the vineyard and killed him.
At that point I thought, Well, now I understand why the pastor called the message "Murder in the Vineyard."
The problem was that I still had no idea what the story actually meant.
I vaguely remembered hearing the parable before, but reading it by itself, it seemed like a strange story about a very patient landowner and some unbelievably wicked tenants. I knew there had to be something deeper going on, so out came the study Bible, and another study Bible, and a study reference book, and another reference book. Yes, I went through four books and explanations about the parable before the picture fully became clear.
That was when the whole passage began to open up.
The vineyard wasn't simply a vineyard.
It represented God's people.
The image itself wasn't new. Hundreds of years earlier, Isaiah had described Israel as the Lord's vineyard:
"The vineyard of the Lord Almighty is the nation of Israel, and the people of Judah are the vines he delighted in." — Isaiah 5:7
God had planted His people, protected them, provided for them, and called them to belong to Him.
That became the opening thought of the song:
You planted a people, You called them Your own You gave them Your promise, Your law and Your home.
The tenants represented the religious leaders—the chief priests and elders who had been entrusted with the spiritual care of the people.
They were supposed to be shepherds.
They were supposed to teach the people God's Word, lead them toward obedience, encourage faith, and point their hearts back toward the One who had called them His own.
God had never given them ownership of His people.
He had given them stewardship.
That difference became one of the central ideas of the song:
Lord, the vineyard is Yours, the people are Yours The harvest was never ours to possess.
The problem Jesus was confronting was that the religious leaders had begun acting as though the vineyard belonged to them.
Instead of using their position to lead people toward God, they had built a religious system that protected their own authority, position, and influence. Jesus repeatedly challenged leaders who cared more about appearances, recognition, and their own status than about the people they were supposed to serve.
In Matthew 23, Jesus says of the teachers of the law and Pharisees:
"Everything they do is done for people to see." — Matthew 23:5
And later:
"They love the place of honor at banquets and the most important seats in the synagogues." — Matthew 23:6
That helped shape another part of the lyric:
But power grew sweeter than serving Your name The tenants forgot You and sought only fame They guarded their places, their titles and wealth.
Then there were the servants the landowner kept sending.
Those servants represented the prophets God had sent throughout Israel's history.
Again and again, God sent men to call His people back to Him. Some were ignored. Some were mocked. Some were imprisoned. Some were killed.
Jesus later said to Jerusalem:
"Jerusalem, Jerusalem, you who kill the prophets and stone those sent to you…" — Matthew 23:37
God kept reaching.
He kept calling.
He kept sending messengers.
That became the second verse:
You sent them the prophets to call them back home But those who held power had hearts that would roam They silenced the servants and hardened their hearts Still You kept waiting for their faith to start.
Then comes the part of the parable that changes everything.
The landowner says, I will send my son.
The son is Jesus.
And suddenly I realized that Jesus wasn't simply telling these religious leaders an interesting story.
He was telling them what they were about to do.
He was standing in front of the chief priests and elders, describing a vineyard owner whose tenants rejected his servants and eventually murdered his son.
And within days, those same religious leaders would help arrange Jesus' death.
Even the detail that the son was taken outside the vineyard is striking.
Matthew 21:39 says:
"So they took him and threw him out of the vineyard and killed him."
Jesus, too, was taken outside the city to be crucified. Hebrews later says:
"And so Jesus also suffered outside the city gate to make the people holy through his own blood." — Hebrews 13:12
What sounded at first like a strange story about a vineyard was actually Jesus describing His own rejection and death before it happened.
That realization gave the second half of the song its direction:
Then finally You said, "I will send them My Son" "Surely they'll honor the One that I love" But outside the vineyard His life was undone And they killed Him believing their kingdom was won.
But the story doesn't end with murder.
Jesus immediately points the religious leaders to Psalm 118:
"The stone the builders rejected has become the cornerstone; the Lord has done this, and it is marvelous in our eyes." — Matthew 21:42; Psalm 118:22–23
The builders rejected the stone.
God made Him the cornerstone.
The religious leaders thought they could remove Jesus and protect their kingdom.
Instead, God made Jesus the foundation of His Kingdom.
That is why the chorus ends:
But what they cast down, You lifted on high Jesus is forever, our Cornerstone.
And that is also where this parable stopped being merely a warning to people who lived two thousand years ago.
It became a warning to me.
And perhaps to all of us who serve in churches, ministries, worship teams, classrooms, leadership positions, or anywhere else God has entrusted people to our care.
The vineyard still belongs to God.
The people still belong to God.
The ministry belongs to God.
The church belongs to God.
The harvest belongs to God.
We are tenants, servants, shepherds and stewards.
We are not the owner.
Paul expressed the same idea when he wrote:
"I planted the seed, Apollos watered it, but God has been making it grow." — 1 Corinthians 3:6
And again:
"For we are co-workers in God's service; you are God's field, God's building." — 1 Corinthians 3:9
That became the prayer in the bridge:
May we never forget for who the vineyard belongs May we never mistake what You've given for us Teach us to listen whenever You call.
Because there is always a temptation to take something God has allowed us to care for and slowly begin treating it as though it belongs to us.
Our church.
Our ministry.
Our music.
Our position.
Our people.
Our way.
And before long, we can become so busy protecting what we think is ours that we begin resisting the very God who gave it to us.
So the bridge continues:
Break every kingdom we build for ourselves For You are the Owner, and Jesus the heir And everything Lord, belongs to You.
That may be the biggest lesson I took away from Matthew 21.
The tenants forgot who owned the vineyard.
And once they forgot that, everything else began to fall apart.
Jesus later says:
"The kingdom of God will be taken away from you and given to a people who will produce its fruit." — Matthew 21:43
God isn't looking for people who simply occupy His vineyard.
He is looking for people who bear fruit in it.
People who love Him.
People who love one another.
People who understand that whatever position, ministry, gift, influence, or opportunity they have been given is something entrusted to them—not something they own.
So what began as a joke among a few bandmates about challenging me to write a song called "Murder in the Vineyard" turned into something much more serious than I expected.
I went into the passage like that little duckling jumping into the pond—unsure what was below the surface.
What I found was a warning about pride, power, stewardship, and the danger of building our own kingdom inside God's vineyard.
But I also found the Gospel.
The Son was rejected.
The Son was taken outside the vineyard.
The Son was killed.
But the stone they rejected did not stay rejected.
God raised Him up.
And now:
The stone once rejected now stands tall The Rock of salvation is the hope for us all So build us together on nothing but Christ Jesus forever is our Cornerstone.
The vineyard is His.
The people are His.
The harvest is His.
And everything, Lord, belongs to You.
As a final comment, and as I've described on the "About" page of this website, I write all of my own songs. Sometimes the lyrics come to me out of the blue, sometimes it's a melody, and every once in a while I'm fortunate enough to get both at the same time. Once the lyrics are written, I normally begin working out the melody and arrangement by playing and recording the primary instruments myself in a Digital Audio Workstation (DAW). After plenty of experimenting, changing, rearranging, deleting, and starting over, a final demo eventually begins to take shape. At that point, I use an AI program to polish the recording and add the final vocals.
This song, however, didn't follow my usual path.
I wrote the lyrics much as I normally would—although this one required a little more biblical research than most—but I was working with an unusually short deadline of only a few days. There simply wasn't enough time to go through my normal process of developing the melody and building the arrangement from scratch, so I sent the finished lyrics directly to AI.
Then came the prompting. Lots and lots of prompting.
I gave it fairly detailed instructions about what I wanted, most of which it seemed quite determined to ignore, and it produced a song that I really didn't like. So I tried again. And again. And again. After somewhere around twenty attempts, along with numerous changes to the prompts, arrangements, styles, and instructions, we finally arrived at the version you can listen to today.
I suppose you could say I cheated on the melody this time. It was certainly faster than my normal way of writing a song, but I can't honestly say it was easier. And while AI can be an amazing tool, bypassing the process of sitting down with an instrument, searching for the right chords, discovering a melody, and watching a song slowly come to life stripped away much of the part I enjoy most.
So, faster? Absolutely.
Easier? Not really.
As much fun? Not even close.